From the end of 2008 the number of new buildings in Bulgaria has decreased by 432 and the number of the apartments in them has decreased by 42.8%.

The greatest number of new apartments still are completed on the Bulgarian Black Sea coast. Only in Burgas district 1136 new apartments have been finished this winter. In second place is Varna district with 727 newly finished apartments, followed by Sofia with 580 and Plovdiv with 265. There are no new apartments in Stara Zagora and Kyustendil.

The area of the newly finished apartments in the first quarter of 2009 is 294 000 sq m which is a decrease by 16% in comparison with the same period of 2008. The size of the average living area has also diminished from 78.3 to 75.5 sq m in the same period.

Property prices in Bulgaria have fallen by 13.57% in the first quarter of 2009 in comparison with the same period last year, according to the Global Property Guide. This time last year the Bulgarian property prices have registered an increase of 16%. Now, in 14 countries the property prices have dropped by more than 10%. The main reason for this tendency in Bulgaria is the drop in the number of foreign buyers.

According to the Global Property Guide the property market is in crisis in 27 out of 32 reviewed countries. The main reasons for this are the growing unemployment, stricter bank rules for landing and diminishing consumer confidence.

Only a few countries experienced increase of property prices. Switzerland is in the first place with a growth of 4% in the first quarter of 2009. The main reason for this is the stable demand supported by falling interest rates and the presence of a great number of foreign buyers. Next are Thailand, Austria and Israel with a price growth of 3%, shortly followed by Shanghai with 1.76%.

Jessie Hewitson, The Observer

Back in 2006, Andrew and Pat Pryce decided to buy an investment property in Bulgaria. With retirement looming, they were hoping for rental income to supplement their pension, and a flat they could eventually sell on at a profit. When they read on the internet about the Mechi Chal mountain lodge in Pamporovo, advertised by overseas property agent Someplace Else as “the most exclusive in Bulgaria’s booming ski resorts” and offering a guaranteed rental yield of 7% a year for the first three years, they put down a deposit of £19,485.

It was a year later, in 2007, that they had the first inkling that something might be wrong. No one was asking them for more money, and there seemed to be no evidence that building was taking place. By 2008, they were so concerned with the lack of progress that they went to Bulgaria and drove around Pamporovo to investigate for themselves.

“We couldn’t see any sign of the development,” says Andrew. “On a second visit we attempted to locate the agency’s Bulgarian office in Plovdiv, but found it inhabited by another company.”

Having lost faith that the development would ever be built, the Pryces asked for their deposit to be returned. They say Someplace Else agreed to this more than a year ago but, despite being promised the money on three occasions, they have received only £2,000. They have now consulted a lawyer.

The Pryces are not alone. Since January 2008, the Association of International Property Professionals (AIPP) – a voluntary organisation with 376 members – has received 116 formal complaints from buyers unhappy about purchases abroad.

The number of people who have lost money in projects around the world is likely to be far higher than most realise, partly because nobody is keeping a record, and partly because those who have lost money are too embarrassed – and upset – to talk about it.

John Howell, senior partner in the International Law Partnership, specialising in overseas property purchases, estimates that 20% of those who have bought off-plan in the past two years are likely to run into “significant difficulty”. According to AIPP estimates, in 2007 193,600 of us bought property in the 10 countries most favoured by British buyers. This means more than 38,000 may be in hot water from just a single year’s overseas property purchases – and some may not even realise it yet.

The collapse of Churchill Properties Overseas alone meant about 340 investors, mainly British and Irish, lost deposits worth an estimated £4m. The company, which sold property in Estonia, Cape Verde and Goa, went into “voluntary liquidation” last summer.

Out of pocket

Another high-profile company, Bulgarian Dreams, closed at the end of 2008 and is currently being investigated by the City of London Police economic crime department. It is impossible to know exactly how many of its investors – who have bought in more than 40 developments in the eastern European country – have been left out of pocket.

Some of the estimated 100-150 investors who, like the Pryces, bought off-plan apartments in the Mechi Chal lodge, are leaving desperate posts on property forums and seeking legal action to get their money back.

Ben Mason, a partner of Someplace Else, says the delays have been caused by the local water authority rescinding permission it had previously granted. He is hoping to get it reinstated. “Providing this happens in the next two months, we can get the first phase finished by December this year and the second phase completed by December next year,” he says.

Mason admits the development is hard to find, but claims that the foundations are in place for phase one, many of the houses have been built off-site and when they do get water permission, the Bulgarian office will reopen.

As for the Pryces’ deposit, he says: “Due to the current economic climate, it has taken us longer than we expected to make this refund from the UK … however, there is no question of the Pryces not receiving the balance of their deposit, with interest, over the next few weeks.”

Howell notes that the developers in trouble are not typically local but British would-be Donald Trumps, and new to the game. “Many of these developers probably started off with good intentions but soon got in over their heads,” he says. “Whether it was fraud or bad economic times is a moot point, frankly, because the end result is the same: people lose money.”

Bad lands

Derek Smythe (not his real name) is more than aware of his predicament, and resigned to losing the £30,000 he invested in 2006 into a company that promised to buy land in Montenegro, get planning permission, build and sell on.

“Since investing the money, I’ve had virtually no communication from the directors [both British],” he says. “There’s no evidence that the money was used to purchase any land at all – I have absolutely no idea what happened to it. It’s been pretty miserable – and the worst thing is, it’s all my fault as I didn’t ask enough questions.”

The sums of money being lost are vast: Howell recently met 70 people, mainly Britons, who had sunk an average of €80,000 (£70,000) into a troubled development in Bulgaria.

He also has clients who regret buying in Dubai. “The problem is that all the major building companies belong to the royal family, and you won’t find a lawyer who will sue.”

The range of people losing money this way spans class, gender and age: young, old, working class, middle class, the gullible, the naive and the greedy are all suffering alike.

“I’ve got clients who are working-class people who invested the £20,000 equity they had in their home, and high-flying professionals who frankly ought to have known better,” says Howell, adding that one client who got stung was a partner in a chartered accountancy firm.

Many of these problems would not have happened if the investors had sought the advice of a good lawyer – something that many of the people interviewed for this article bitterly regret not doing.

The Bulgarian property market has entered into a constant slum and it is expected that the earliest in 2011 it will pick up, according to developers, analysts and estate agents.

This conclusion is based on the expectation for a deep recession in the country in the next two years. Prominent business analysts think that the recovery of the property market in Bulgaria entirely depends on the economic development of the country. The boom of the property market coincided with the economic boom. However, now the forecast of the IMF for Bulgaria is most worrying – recession in the next two years, high unemployment and shrinking of the spending. Traditionally, the economic process in Bulgaria lags behind the one in the developed Western countries. Only in case that Bulgaria starts using the European funds properly and more companies from Western Europe relocate in Bulgaria by 2010 the country will reach the lowest point of the economic recession and the economy will start moving upwards.

According to the IMF report about Bulgaria, 3,5 billion BGN from the planned budget income will not be collected in 2009 due to the recession. This will mean automatic activation of the so-called 10% rule – shrinking of the expenses of all ministries and government agencies by 10% in order to achieve an annual budget with a small profit.

The current IMF mission in Bulgaria aims to establish the economic situation in the country. The most dramatic development is the inability to collect VAT to the value of about 3 billion BGN from the initially planned amounts. The most optimistic forecast of the National Revenue Agency is that the VAT collection will be 5% less than the planned for 2009 or an amount exceeding 110 million BGN, which still will be an increase of 6% in comparison to last year.

Generally, the tax collection might increase by 12% in comparison with last year.

Concerning the collection of Capital Gain Tax, the optimistic forecast underlines that 14% or 360 million BGN will not be collected. Still the collection of Capital Gain Tax will be 2% more than last year.

According to the IMF report, the decrease of income will force Bulgaria cut the budget expenses to the value of 1,7 billion BGN in 2009. The state expenses must be cut, as well as the salary increases, because the economic growth in 2009 will slow down to 1%.

The decrease of lending and of the foreign investment will lead to the shrinking of sales in the country. This in combination with the decrease of property prices and the possible increase of the number of bad debt might lead to shrinking of the economy and a negative GDP growth of – 3,5%, according to the pessimistic forecast of the IMF.

Sofia is in third place among the European capitals in terms of profitability of office space. A high quality office building can have a 10% annual return. Only the Russian capital Moscow (11.5%) and the Ukrainian capital Kiev (14%) are rating better than Sofia. The profitability of office space in the Bulgarian capital has increased by 3% or 300 points from its lowest position three years ago. The figures for Belgrade are similar – 10% – while for the other Balkan cities this ratio varies from 7% to 8.5%. Only offices in the Romanian capital Bucharest show higher annual return of 9.5%. The more developed markets of office space like Prague, Budapest and Warsaw have much lower levels of annual returns of 6.75 % – 7.75%.

The rent of office space in the Bulgarian capital has actually decreased by 6.85% in the last year and now is 17 EUR/sq.m. on average as it is linked to the decreasing prices of properties in general. There is similar decrease of office rent in Madrid, Dublin, Moscow, Kiev, Belgrade, Budapest, Warsaw and Bucharest. In the 15 older EU-member states the office rent has decreased by 4% on average.

Despite the financial and economic crisis, the market of agricultural land will stay relatively active in 2009 but the prices will fall, according to the Bulgarian Deputy Agricultural Minister Svetla Bachvarova. In her annual analysis of the agricultural land market she said that there has been an increase of more than 21% of the market in comparison with 2007. The average price of the deals in the last year has been 312 levs per 1000 sq m, according to the System for Agricultural Market Information. This is an increase of almost 33% of the market values in comparison with 2008. The prediction for this year is that they will fall to 280-300 levs per 1000 sq m. The differences in the prices for the different regions of the country remain. The lowest prices are in the area of Lovech and Pernik, relatively 201 lv per 1000 sq m and 140 lv per 1000 sq m. The highest prices are in Dobrich – 546 levs per 1000 sq m.
In 2008 for the second consecutive year the highest number of purchases of land took place in the Northern Central area.
There is a decrease in the renting of agricultural land. This was due to the fact that in 2008 and 2007 a larger part of the tenants have signed long-term contracts for more than four years with the land owners.
The regulation of agricultural land has decreased in the last year by 20% in comparison with 2007. The reason is the decreased interest for investment in tourism.
In 2009 it is expected that the area of the land for growing agricultural production will stay the same and only the land used for growing wheat will increase by 10%.

The Bulgarian ski resort Bansko was a typical example of the “hot market” in Easter Europe. Now, the small town is an example for the exactly the opposite.
The balloon has burst and the market of holiday properties in Bulgaria has collapsed. With this, sank the dreams for fast returns of many investors who have poured money into the region. Bansko is an emblem of the end of the hot market of holiday properties in the region. Most often the investors in the region are Brits and Irish who relied on the rental market or on the sharply increasing prices. The locals have earned some cash by selling their land, but the charm of the small town with small houses and narrow streets has disappeared forever. Now there are huge hotels and the roads are either made wider to cope with the traffic or are under construction. The holiday property market has suffered more than any other during the recession. The number of purchases has decreased by 10% at the end of the last year. The property boom in Bulgaria started in 2002 and the pivotal points were Bansko and some Black Sea resorts like Sunny Beach.
Now, when the market has collapsed, the biggest advantage of the situation take investment funds which buy properties in great numbers in the resorts at low prices and wait for the market to recover, the buyers to return and the prices to start going up again. There are buyers who are not so happy. Many British owners who bought their apartments at the Black Sea a year ago at prices exceeding 1000 Euros per square metre are ready to sell them now for as little as 500 Euros per square metre.

Russians started buying apartments in Bulgaria in bulks of 300. They buy everything at prices ranging from 300 Euros to expensive attic apartments at 2000 Euros per sq m. The Russians are attracted by the drop of prices in Bulgaria which exceeds 20% in comparison with last year. “We buy properties in bulk!” is written on billboards on the streets in Sofia and in the Bulgarian Black Sea resorts. Many Russians have decided to invest heavily in property in Bulgaria in an attempt to protect their savings in the climate of uncertainty about the future of the major Russian banks. At the same time this is badly needed influx of fresh money on the Bulgarian property market.

Because of the recession many sellers drop the prices of their properties to be able to sell them. The number of prices of apartments in the big Bulgarian cities which are under 30 000 Euros have drastically increased in the first three months of this year. One of the reasons for this is the lack of buyers due to the strict rules of the bank for lending. A few months ago all Bulgarian banks stopped lending money for the purchase of apartment in prefabricated blocks from the communist era. After that the banks have sharply increased the mortgage interest rates and have decreased the size of the mortgages, thus have put off many prospective buyers. In reality the Bulgarian property market have moved back to the situation years ago of expensive mortgages.

In Plovdiv 70 apartments are on the market for prices under 30 000 Euros. Only 20 of them are off plan. Prefabricated apartments with total area exceeding 90 sq m are for sale for as little as 13 000 Euros.
In Varna the number of the apartments under 30 000 Euros is 60, the cheapest property is a one-bedroom apartment for 20 000 Euros in the outskirts of the city. There is ever an apartment in the central parts of Varna offered at 30 000 Euros, which is still at the off-plan stage. Prefabricated apartments sell for about 25 000 Euros in the outskirts of Varna.

In the second largest city on the Black Sea, Burgas, the number of apartments on offer are twice more than in Varna but most of them are off-plan and in the outskirts of the city. The cheapest offer, €15 120, is for an off-plan apartment with are of 41 sq m. There are ten prefabricated properties for sale at prices starting at 24 000 Euros. All of them are located in the outskirts of Burgas.

In Russe there are 20 apartments under 30 000 Euros. The cheapest offer is for a studio for 12 900 Euros. Prefabricated apartments start at 15 000 Euros.

While in the country at the moment prices range from 440 to 580 Euros per sq m, in the capital Sofia, the property prices have dropped everywhere, apart from the central parts of the city. The sharpest drop of prices is in the southern parts of the city where there are more unfinished buildings then anywhere else in the city. The prices of prefabricated apartments have fallen more than any other. While last year they used to sell for more than 1000 Euros per sq m, now they are on offer for under 750 Euros per sq. m. Newly finished properties are offered for 700 – 800 Euros sq m. Off-plan apartments are offered for 500 Euros per sq m. Some developers offer discounts of 20 % of the prices of their finished apartments in cases of payment in cash. Others who are stable financially offer 15 leasing schemes to their customers.

The real increase of property prices in Bulgaria for the last year was 2.25% according to the Global Property Guide. This puts the country in the fourth place for price increase among 32 property markets across the world. In 2007 the nominal property price increase in Bulgaria was 19.68%. The United Arab Emirates hold the first place for 2008 with a price increase of 40.86%. Shanghai in China is in second place with 4.83% and Switzerland is in third place with 4%. Nominally, without taking the inflation into account, Bulgaria is in second place with a price increase for 2008 of 11.72%.

The property market in Bulgaria showed a decrease of 5.31% taking the inflation into account or nominally 4.15% in the last three months of 2008.

In the last year the property prices have increased only in eight of the 32 countries taking part in the survey, while in 20 there has been a decrease when compared with the inflation. In 2007 the situation was strikingly different – only in six of the countries there was a price decrease, while in 24 there has been an increase of the property prices.

In 2008 in Bulgaria the number of purchases of property was 309 788 which was 4.79 % less than in 2007 when their number was 325 385.
The direct foreign investment in property in Bulgaria in the first nine months of 2008 amounted to 1190.5 million Euros which is a decrease of 33.34% in comparison to 2007. At the same time the direct foreign investment in construction in the same period showed a decrease of 27.99% and amounted to 405.2 million Euros.
The average property price increase in Bulgaria for 2008 was 14.88% due to the expansion of the construction industry in the first half of the year unlike the stalemate of the last months. The average increase of the rent was 4.74%. Most of the buyers in 2008 were Bulgarians and Russians. The average monthly yield in 2008 was 6.34% which is about the average for Europe. In Sofia it was 5.89%, in the second largest Bulgarian city Varna it was 4.97%, while in Plovdiv, the third city it was 4.86%.
The average mortgage in February was 36 100 Euros. Mostly people who have savings able to cover 40% of the price of the property take mortgages at the moment. In Sofia the average mortgage was 45 200 Euros, in Varna – 36 140 Euros, and in Plovdiv – 25 400 Euros. Nobody takes mortgages exceeding
70 000 Euros at the moment and the banks do not lend mortgage which cover 80% or 90% of the price of the property.

Рublished in the Financial Times

By Kerin Hope and Theodor Troev in Sofia

There are warning signals everywhere, yet the European Union’s poorest member insists it can weather the global financial crisis.

Standard and Poor’s last month downgraded Bulgaria’s long-term debt to BBB. Fitch this month cut its rating to BBB- just one notch above junk bond status.

On Friday, the Bulgarian Industrial Association urged the finance ministry to redraft next year’s budget and cut the growth forecast from 4.7 per cent to 2 per cent of gross domestic product.

“We are witnessing an unprecedented global crisis… for the first time, the tensions in Bulgaria’s economy are caused not by internal but by foreign factors,” the association said.

However, Plamen Oresharski, the finance minister, rejects a suggestion that after bail-outs of Hungary and Ukraine by the International Monetary Fund, Bulgaria may be among the next in line.

“We are not in a similar position. Our banking system looks sound, with a good level of liquidity and healthy reserves,” he said. “Our concerns about the real economy are greater, but we still expect comparatively strong growth next year.”

Thanks to a record grain harvest, the economy is projected to expand this year by 6.9 per cent.

But the current account deficit – the highest in south-east Europe at about 24 per cent of GDP – appears unsustainable given an accelerating decline in foreign direct investment.

Investment inflows fell 48 per cent in the third quarter, according to central bank figures, following the collapse of a holiday-home construction bubble and a freeze on transfers by eurozone banks to their Bulgarian subsidiaries.

“Construction has been the most important growth driver, even more than in Spain, so the outlook is grave,” said Lubomir Christoff, a former chief economist at the central bank.

Sergey Stanishev, prime minister, has suggested Bulgaria should join the EU’s exchange rate mechanism next year. But although Bulgaria can point to a budget surplus and a low public debt (about 18 per cent of GDP), an annual inflation rate above 10 per cent rules out any chance of an early entry to the euro.

Mr Oresharski argues that an accumulated fiscal surplus of Lev12bn ($7.8bn, €6.2bn, £5.2bn) provides a cushion.

“One relief is that the government doesn’t have any short-term borrowing requirements,” he said.

In spite of rapid credit expansion since EU accession last year, total bank indebtedness is still low at about 30 per of GDP.

Lending is tight because foreign banks have lost access to funding from parent groups squeezed by the global credit crunch.

“We’ve been told to rely on our own resources, which means lending will slow,” said a senior executive at a foreign-owned bank.

Bulgaria’s currency board, which pegs the lev to the euro, is intended to eliminate foreign exchange risk. The arrangement also requires that money in circulation does not exceed central bank reserves.

With reserves at 180 per cent of currency in circulation, the lev was buttressed against an all-out attack on the currency board, Mr Oresharski said.

But other currency boards in the Baltics look less stable following Latvia’s request last week for EU help to fend off a crisis.

The slowing down of the Bulgarian property market is most obvious at the Black Sea resorts, namely the Sunny Beach and the Golden Sands, and in the mountain ski resorts like Bansko and Pamporovo. The price of properties there have reached their peak levels and the number of purchases has been falling. There is no demand for such properties, while the the properties on offer are many. This is the reason why the Bulgarian banks avoid financing such purchases, as well as the construction of properties along the coast. According to leading business and legal advisers, the prospective investors can not  rely on off-plan sales at the moment. Many hotels along the Bulgarian Black Sea coast have been put up for sale and there are no prospective buyers interested in them. This means that most of them will be acquired by the Bulgarian banks which credited their construction. In the long run if the intensive construction does not stop, many hotels along the coast will have to be demolished like in Spain. However, in order to do this, a new legislative framework needs to be introduced by the Bulgarian parliament, and leading solicitors have been investigating the Spanish experience and preparing the necessary amendments to the current Bulgarian laws. Generally, the lawyers and the law companies seem to be more occupied than anybody else involved in the construction business.

Away from the Black Sea and the mountain resorts, the Bulgarian property market keeps moving because traditionally Bulgarians consider buying a property not only an investment but  most of all a form of security.

Despite the looming global financial crisis. New developments open in the Bulgarian Black Sea resort of Sunny Beach.

Oasis VIP Homes and Blue Pearl Apartment Complex in Sunny Beach will be presented at the largest property exhibition on the Balkans – BalPex. Oasis VIP Homes is the first luxury development of Galaxy Property Group in Sunny Beach. The development is in Mediterranean style with a park of more than 10 000 sq.m. and with three swimming pools. This project includes also Royal Sun development with 530 apartments.

The other project Blue Pearl is a development with apartments situated in the central part of the Sunny Beach. It comprises of 85 apartments overlooking the bay with Nessebar and St. Vlas, 16 shops, barber shop, gym and two swimming pools with a bar.

Despite the financial crisis, the property prices in the suburbs of Sofia have been constantly increasing due to the migration of people from smaller towns and villages who seek employment in the capital. In the last year, more than 30 000 people have relocated to Sofia, while 12 000 people have moved to Varna, the second largest Bulgarian city. The same tendency can be seen in Plovdiv, Russe and Burgas. The newcomers to the cities usually look for cheaper properties in the suburds. As result the prices of apartments in those areas keep rising. The average porperty price in Sofia is 1094 Euros per square metre, while in the county it is 588 Euros per square metre. The studios seem to be very popular and their sales have increased by 17% in the last months. At the same time the demand for one-bedroom apartments have decreased by 28% and of larger apartments by 3%. Most of the sales are of newly built properties.

The Bulgarian banks have introduced tougher rules for lending money after two days of stopping crediting. Now they lend money only for the purchase of properties which can be easily sold if reposessed. Families with total income under 1500 levs per month can not take a mortgage to purchase an apartment in one of the larger cities. To such families the banks offer only small size credits with monthly instalments not exceeding 50 Euros. While in the past the banks were satisfied if the monthly repayment instalments were up to 50% of the total income of a family, now they restrict the instalments to not more than 39% of the monthly income. The average mortgage interest is 8.2% per annum and the average instalment is 360 Euros per month, which is an increas of 40 Euros for the last six moths.

The collapse of the banks in the West is a serious warning for the future of Bulgarian banks. In the last three-four years, the Bulgarian banks enjoyed enormous profit and record growth levels but the world financial crisis is going to put an end to this.

Almost all Bulgarian banks have started to change their development policy following September, 14.  Almost all plans for the opening of new branches have been frozen. The major problem in the banking sector is the lack of fresh money. The foreign financing has stopped and now all Bulgarian banks have focused on the domestic market to keep their growth. It is expected that a within a year a real war to attract deposits of new clients will unleash and the perks for the clients will include holidays abroad and golden watches.

However the biggest loser will be the business and the ordinary consumer. Many banks have changed their policy to attract new clients and now focus on keep the reliable clients with a good track record. It will be very difficult to get a credit if you are a new company. The price of this will be high for the Bulgarian economy – so far the banks have been the major force of the economic growth.

The management of the Bulgarian Stock Exchange survived the non-confidence vote after it received the support of the state at the shareholders meeting. The Ministry of Finance holds 44% of share capital of the stock exchange and rejected all proposals for the change of the management.