Jack Fagan, Irish Times

AROUND THIS time of year, the newspapers are generally packed with large ads for overseas real estate. That has been going on for over a decade but, in recent years, Bulgaria and other former Eastern Bloc countries have been particularly active in targeting Irish buyers who had a reputation for being big spenders during the Celtic Tiger years.

These overseas property ads are rarely, if ever, seen any more simply because Bulgaria’s real estate boom has turned to bust and Irish and UK buyers are fleeing due to rapidly falling values and the rising number of uncompleted developments.

Other former Eastern Bloc countries are suffering the same fate.

Bulgaria became a particular favourite for many Irish investors because holiday homes were frequently available at half, or even one-third, of the price of similar properties on the Costa del Sol. Attracted by unrealistic promises of exceptional returns, Irish investors had no hesitation in borrowing heavily to buy cheap buy-to-let homes.

Dublin mortgage agents say that, because of the refusal of Irish banks generally to fund property investments in Bulgaria, many purchasers released equity from their homes or Irish-based property investments. Others used hot money in the belief that the Revenue had enough on its plate in tracing second homes and investments in Spain, France, Portugal and other popular destinations without traipsing through the former Eastern Bloc.

“A great deal of the money invested in Bulgaria never appeared on the radar. It would be hard to trace,” says one of Dublin’s largest mortgage lenders.

Tom McGrath, a Dublin solicitor specialising in the overseas residential markets, says that a combination of naivety and greed led many Irish people to buy up to five properties in Bulgaria with the intention of “flipping” them on before they were completed to make a profit.

Any number of estate agents had recommended this as a fool-proof way of making money but the reality was different and they have been left “with properties that they do not want, cannot sell and cannot afford to complete on”.

The market in Bulgaria is over-supplied and pretty well on the floor. Real estate agencies say that at least one-third of the 2,200 foreign-owned holiday flats in Bansko – one of the country’s top ski towns – are on the block again, often at half price.

One media report has suggested that some Black Sea hotel owners have offered their debt-laden businesses for sale for €1 – grim news for tourism, Bulgaria’s top foreign investment sector.

The property market in Bulgaria, like Ireland, has had a hard landing. Construction firms have been laying off workers and, with bank borrowing getting more difficult, many developers are finding it increasingly hard to complete schemes.

McGrath says that promises of guaranteed rent from developers are often unfulfilled and these properties were overvalued in the first instance to take account of this arrangement.

Investment in the property sector, which accounted for 30 to 40 per cent of GNP in the past few years, brought an immediate profit, says local economist Tihomir Bezlov: “Real estate for Bulgaria was like oil and gold for other countries.”

The same could probably be said of Ireland but, unlike Bulgaria, there was never any suspicion here that the industry was being used to launder money from criminal proceeds.

Bulgaria’s authorities have admitted they cannot prove where the money that fed the boom came from. Could some of the proceeds of the Northern Bank robbery in Belfast in 2004 be in the Black Sea? There’s a thought.

Irish estate agencies offer holiday apartments in the Bulgarian resorts at prices which 35% lower than the original ones. Part of the offer is that if the purchase is completed by the end of the month the buyers will save further 500 Euros.

In Sunny Beach on the Black Sea cost the cheapest offer is 24 990 Euros for a studio apartment. At the same time in the ski resort of Bansko studios are on offer for 20 000 Euros and generally prices at the mountain resorts are lower.

For the first time in four years there are clear signs that the interest towards holiday homes in Bulgaria has decreased. The major buyers on this market – the Irish and the English – have stopped buying. The estate agents now joke that the result of this crisis is exactly what the greens have been striving to achieve – there is no construction in the resorts whatsoever.

According to the analysts, the slump has come as a natural result of the wish of the developers to constantly increase the number of foreign buyers, taking advantage of the low prices. At the moment there are no buyers at all and many developers sell their properties well below their value. Those few developers who have free cash despite the recession do not want to invest in the overdeveloped Black Sea and mountain resorts. There the property prices have dropped so much that a studio costs as much as a new middle class car. Despite this, there are no buyers. The supply on the holiday property market is 80% higher than the demand. There are thousands of sellers and no buyers. There is no secondary market due to the low rental income.

40 000 Euros can buy you a furnished one bedroom apartment in Sunny Beach. Most buyers receive not only discounts but also fitted kitchens, furniture or at least laminated floor.

In Bansko the situation looks similar. A one bedroom apartment of 80 sq m, situated close to the gondola lift costs 38 000 Euros. Further away from the lift in the direction of the central parts of the town price fall and for 30 000 Euros investors can buy an apartment of 64 sq m. Completed furnished apartments sell for about 600 Euros per sq m.

Although the holiday homes market has reached new lows, the analysts believe that in long term there will be good prospects for its development. The recession itself has lead to to preservation of the nature and this will eventually attract new buyers and tourists. On the other hand the recession has brought new lower prices of materials and labour. Many companies which got involved in construction because of the high profits are now going bankrupt. The developers are becoming more careful and there are expectations that the new projects will be of much better quality and with better location.

Regardless of the fact that the British and Irish buyers have lost interest towards the Bulgarian market, the analysts expect that soon Russians, Poles and Scandinavians will start buying in great numbers in Bulgaria. However, they look for different products and it seems that what has been built for the British buyers will not satisfy them. The holiday apartment or house will be less important than the environment, the peace and quiet, and the services on offer.

The Bulgarian ski resort Bansko was a typical example of the “hot market” in Easter Europe. Now, the small town is an example for the exactly the opposite.
The balloon has burst and the market of holiday properties in Bulgaria has collapsed. With this, sank the dreams for fast returns of many investors who have poured money into the region. Bansko is an emblem of the end of the hot market of holiday properties in the region. Most often the investors in the region are Brits and Irish who relied on the rental market or on the sharply increasing prices. The locals have earned some cash by selling their land, but the charm of the small town with small houses and narrow streets has disappeared forever. Now there are huge hotels and the roads are either made wider to cope with the traffic or are under construction. The holiday property market has suffered more than any other during the recession. The number of purchases has decreased by 10% at the end of the last year. The property boom in Bulgaria started in 2002 and the pivotal points were Bansko and some Black Sea resorts like Sunny Beach.
Now, when the market has collapsed, the biggest advantage of the situation take investment funds which buy properties in great numbers in the resorts at low prices and wait for the market to recover, the buyers to return and the prices to start going up again. There are buyers who are not so happy. Many British owners who bought their apartments at the Black Sea a year ago at prices exceeding 1000 Euros per square metre are ready to sell them now for as little as 500 Euros per square metre.

By Anna Mikhailova, The Times

When Maryla Guzinska, a housewife from the Isle of Wight, read an article in a national newspaper extolling the virtues of property on the Estonian riviera, it seemed like a sound investment. In June 2005, she put down a deposit of £10,500 on a two-bedroom villa in Parnu, the seaside “summer capital” of the Baltic state, and was told her new holiday home would be ready by the end of the next year, when the remainder of the £42,500 sale price would be due.

Churchill Properties Overseas, which was building and selling the villas, assured Guzinska that her home would double in price in the 18 months or so it would take to build, thanks to the property boom under way in the former Soviet republic. Guzinska, 49, believed them – not least because the company was based near her on the Isle of Wight. When she went to the office, the salesman was “professional and well spoken” (even if, in retrospect, she recalls that he never looked her in the eye).

The completion date came and went, however, and in the months that followed, Guzinska was repeatedly told that her home on the Churchill Village development had been delayed.

Then, last July, she received a letter from Churchill Innovative Solutions – as the company appeared to have renamed itself – saying that it had been put into “voluntary liquidation”. Guzinska began to doubt that she would ever see her £10,500 again. “I was hoping to buy something that would be an investment and a holiday home,” she says. “Now I’m on a debt management programme.”
Related Links

Gary Fensome, a company director from Luton, has also lost hope of recovering the £12,000 he invested in a one-bedroom flat in the same development. “I’m furious and I want my money back,” says Fensome, 48. “When Churchill showed me the site in 2006, it looked lovely. It all sounded reputable. But for the next year I had to keep chasing them for receipts, then it emerged that nothing was being built.”

Churchill – which had a local office in Parnu, but sold its off-plan log cabins and villas largely to British customers – is not believed to have obtained planning permission for Churchill Village or for two other developments in Parnu, Audru Golf and Parnu River (although it appears to have received it for a fourth one). As a result, no building work had started on the land, even though Churchill gave the impression to investors that the projects were in full swing.

In the meantime, hundreds of investors are left wondering what has happened to their deposits, which total more than £1.5m. Hampshire Constabulary confirmed that two men, aged 40 and 44, were arrested on suspicion of theft in August and November last year, respectively, and released on bail until this August. No charges have been brought. They are thought to be Paul Wade, 40, and Karl Goldthorpe, 44, both directors of the company.

In an attempt to recoup their losses, 120 of the investors have signed up to the Action Against Churchills group (actionagainstchurchills.blogspot.com), founded last summer, but are frustrated at the lack of progress. “We’ve given up hope of getting our money back,” says Guzinska’s husband, Clive Bowley, a spokesman for the group, who separately invested just over £14,000 in another Churchill villa. “Lawyers tell us it will cost £100,000 to fight our case, so it’s out of the question.” Churchill – which has no connection with the insurance company of the same name – did not respond to requests for comment from The Sunday Times.

Estonia is not the only place where Britons have seen hopes of easy profits turn to dust. During the boom years of this decade, property abroad – once the preserve of the wealthy – became all too accessible for anyone with a few thousand pounds for a deposit and, ideally, a UK home from which to withdraw equity. Teachers, civil servants, social workers and academics all piled in. It was, in the words of salesmen, a “no-brainer”: you put down a deposit on an off-plan flat, chalet or villa, then sat back and waited for the profits to roll in.

Since the credit crunch struck and world economies hit the buffers, however, the laws of gravity have come back into play with a vengeance. It is not just that many buyers have seen the capital gains on which they were counting turn into losses as property prices across Europe – and beyond – continue to spiral downward.

More serious is the impact that the downturn has had on the developers who were meant to be building those homes. Many have run out of money, leaving properties unbuilt and developments as little more than ghost towns. In other cases – such as that of Churchill Properties Overseas – there are doubts as to whether they ever intended to build anything in the first place.

John Howell, senior partner in the International Law Partnership (ILP), which specialises in overseas property purchases, says he has seen a fivefold increase in the number of clients with problems over the past 12 months. In the same period, the number requiring conveyancing has dropped by 70% as sales have plunged. “Developers are either going bankrupt or the development is not as specified,” Howell says. “One of the first things that happens when developers are in trouble is that they start stripping back on expensive items.”

The problem, he says, has been especially acute in the “emerging markets” of eastern Europe, whose economies – until recently the most dynamic on the continent – have been hit hard. Matters have been made worse by the way in which some local developers teamed up with foreign estate agents in the hope of selling to gullible foreigners at inflated prices.

“In places such as Bulgaria, everybody wants to become a developer, and as well as illegal building, you get oversupply in a market that is always going to be a marginal one,” Howell says.

ILP is representing a number of clients who bought property from Bulgarian Dreams, a London-based estate agency that folded last year, but have yet to take possession of their homes.

Founded and owned by Robert Jenkin, a Cambridge graduate, and his Bulgarian wife, Mariya Georgieva, the company sold flats and houses at more than 40 developments in Sofia, the capital, in ski resorts such as Bansko and Pamporovo, and on the Black Sea coast.

A message on the Bulgarian Dreams website says that the company has ceased trading “following the extraordinarily difficult economic conditions” and suggests those who bought property through it should contact the Bulgarian developers directly.

One of the three companies it names is Interlink BG, of which Georgieva was a “manager”. Jenkin insists, however, that the position did not give his wife similar powers to those of the director of a British company, and says she took it merely so she could “have better access to information regarding the developments”.

Bulgarian Dreams is being investigated by the City of London Police Economic Crime Department. “We have received a number of complaints about Bulgarian Dreams and have begun an investigation,” a spokeswoman says. She confirmed that the company closed its Moorgate offices at the end of 2008, but could not comment further.

Indy Gill, 45, an accountant from Nottingham, and his wife, Kim, 44, who runs a nursery, are among those ruing the day they invested in Bulgaria. In 2005, he says, he paid Bulgarian Dreams a £15,930 deposit on a £55,000 penthouse flat in the first phase of the Windows to Paradise complex in Balchik, on the Bulgarian Black Sea coast, which was due to be completed in December 2006.

Early in 2007, having heard nothing, Gill says he contacted Bulgarian Dreams and was told that, due to planning problems, the top floor of the building, with the penthouse, would not be built – and he would instead be given a flat in the development’s third phase, due to be completed a year or so later.

Then, this year, he received a letter from Bulgarian Dreams informing him that it was no longer acting as agent for the development – and told him to deal directly with Interlink BG instead. Despite sending the Bulgarian-based company repeated e-mails, Gill has heard nothing, and says he fears work has not even started on the third phase in which his flat is meant to be. “We’ve got absolutely nothing to show for our money,” says Gill. “I’ve resigned myself to losing my £16,000, but my wife still wants to do something, so we are trying, though a Bulgarian lawyer, to recover our money.”

In a statement to The Sunday Times, Jenkin insists his company is working with Bulgarian developers to resolve problems with projects in the country with which it has been involved. “If any delays or issues exist with a development, they are due to the current economic conditions affecting all of the property industry,” he says.

Most of the investors who have lost out in schemes in Bulgaria, Estonia or elsewhere put their money into projects that seemed completely above board and were, in some cases, recommended by independent financial advisers. In retrospect, however, some buyers appear to have been simply too trusting – especially when developments were being sold by British-based agents.

“A lot of people never took legal advice, never got an independent valuation or never checked the deeds,” says Simon Conn, technical consultant to Conti Financial Services, which specialises in overseas mortgages. “Many overpaid for their property even before the credit crunch struck, and now these homes are worth even less.” In many cases, Conn says, buyers took advice from a lawyer recommended to them by the developer. Others made the mistake of signing an “English version” of their contract rather than obtaining an accurate translation.

Nor is it just in eastern Europe that things have gone wrong. Hundreds of Britons are reported to have lost money in an alleged £24m housing scam in Orlando, Florida. This month, court documents were filed in America on behalf of a class action against the Superior Homes & Investments estate agency, accusing the company of defrauding customers by taking payments for homes that were never built. More than 500 people paid deposits of up to £217,000.

In Calabria, southern Italy, meanwhile, British and Irish investors have run into difficulties with properties they have purchased. One of the biggest developments in the region, the Jewel of the Sea, was blocked for environmental reasons. Last month, 120 illegally built flats, valued at a total of £28m, in the Santa Venere and Marinate resorts at Vibo Marina were sequestered by police. The El Caribe scheme, where 90 investors have paid deposits totalling £4m, was due to be completed in May, but work has not started.

Then, of course, there is Spain, where a mixture of collapsing property companies, arbitrarily implemented government rules, and out-and-out fraud have put paid to the property dreams of many British buyers.

Last year, Spanish police broke up For-tuna Land, an organisation they claimed had cheated foreign investors, predominantly from Britain and Ireland, out of £61m. As many as 2,000 people are believed to have lost money – some as much as £500,000 each – after investing in the developments in Andalusia.

Others, such as Paul Sibley, 45, an electrician from Luton, have been caught out by the collapse of Martinsa-Fadesa, one of Spain’s biggest developers, which filed for court protection from its creditors last year.

In 2005, Sibley put down a €119,000 deposit on a €400,000 villa on the La Oliva Golf development, near Corralejo, in the north of Fuerteventura, one of the Canary Islands. Although the property was already built when he paid his money, the golf course was not, and problems in obtaining a licence for the course, compounded by the discovery of an archeological site, delayed completion. Then, in the middle of last year, Martinsa-Fadesa went down.

“Work stopped before they finished the access road and the mains water connection,” Sibley says. “I would consider completing without the golf course, if the price was reduced enough, but not without access and water.”

Sibley hopes that the administrators will make finishing the development a priority for Martinsa-Fadesa. If not, his money could be tied up for years. “We decided to invest because the developer was the biggest in Spain, listed on the stock exchange – a blue-chip developer,” he says. “It should have been one of the safest.”

Anna Micklewright, a senior NHS purchasing manager from Cheshire, paid a 30% deposit of €39,000 in January 2006 for an off-plan two-bedroom semidetached house in Jumilla Golf, Murcia. Then, last May, the developer, Herrada del Tollo SL, was obliged to seek voluntary protection from its creditors. Although companies can recover from administration, this is difficult at the best of times – let alone during the current economic conditions.

“The administrators are now in charge, but millions of euros that the developer took in deposits seem to have disappeared,” says Micklewright, 33, adding that under Spanish law, those deposits should have been ring-fenced. “It’s a disaster for hundreds of British buyers who have lost their savings. It is especially tough on those who moved out to Spain to live in rented accommodation provided by the developer while waiting for their retirement homes. They have been evicted.”

“Some 95% of the buyers at Jumilla Golf don’t have a bank guarantee, even though many were told that they did, and they only found out they didn’t when the developer went into administration,” Micklewright says. In her case, she says, they insisted on – and obtained – a guarantee from a bank called Banco Pastor, but were not sure whether this would mean they would be compensated.

Micklewright has complained to the Foreign Office, her MP, her MEP and the Bank of Spain. “In Spain, developers and banks announce that they are not going to honour contracts, and lawyers just shrug their shoulders,” she says.

There are still bargains abroad to be found, explains Laura Latham, The Independent

House prices may be dropping across Europe, but the strength of the euro has put British buyers off destinations such as Spain and France. However, there are countries where you can still find good-value property.

“You get more for your money in Turkey, when compared to Spain or popular Greek resorts,” says Janet Schofield of the Turkish specialists Nicholas Homes. “Prices haven’t gone up lately, and there are definitely good deals, such as two-bedroom apartments from around £40,000 and villas with pools for around £140,000.”

Schofield says there’s also increasing demand for rental property as holidaymakers shun the Eurozone for cheaper destinations, which benefits owners who want to let their homes.

It’s a similar story in Croatia, where the market has dipped due to global economic woes. “Sellers are having to reduce prices as there are less buyers,” says Andrea Marston of Investment Group Croatia. “British vendors in particular can afford to drop as they’re still better off when they convert their money into sterling. So it’s worth negotiating.”

Marston has properties on the attractive Dalmatian coast, ranging from £90,000 for two bedrooms to three-bedroom villas with a pool for around £220,000. She claims it’s better value than Spain, where buying cheap “often means you’re a 10-minute drive from the sea, rather than a few minutes’ walk”.

Bulgaria has fallen out of favour recently, but the low cost of living means that tourism is expected to pick up. Despite sterling having lost value against the Bulgarian lev, prices are still reasonable, with apartments selling for as little as £30,000 in ski resorts such as Borovets and Bansko, and on the Black Sea coast.

“A one-bedroom new-build in the French Alps will start at £180,000, while one-bedrooms in our Bulgarian projects start at £35,500, with duplexes from £75,500,” says Veneta Cornford of Zoldi. “Coastal properties start at around the same price. We’re seeing a lot of interest in rentals, too.”

Low prices can also still be found in Morocco, which is attracting buyers who have been priced out of Europe. Apartments costing from £25,000 are in new purpose-built resorts on the Mediterranean coast around Tangier, but these areas are less popular than the cities.

Frances McKay of Francophiles says it’s possible to find lovely riads for the price of a Spanish apartment. “Marrakech is popular, but has become expensive, though you can still find renovated riads with three or four bedrooms for £260,000, and nice one-bedroom apartments from £89,000,” she says. “In Fez, we have traditional properties in need of updating from £50,000.”

McKay also has apartments and characterful properties in Essaouira, a pretty town on the Atlantic coast, from around £70,000, which she thinks are “unbelievable” bargains. “You won’t get much on Europe’s Mediterranean coast for that.”

Bargain properties: A buyer’s guide

* Be wary of buying cheap property through developers or agents with no track record. The quality may be substandard or the company could be unethical or go bust.

* Check if your chosen agent or developer is a member of a professional organisation, such as the Federation of Overseas Property Developers, Agents and Consultants (www.fopdac.com).

* Currency markets can be volatile, so it’s worth changing money via a specialist broker to get the best rate.

* Many international markets may have further to fall. Research your chosen location so that you’re ready to take advantage of any price drops.

Because of the lack of demand in the last year the prices of rural properties fell dramatically. Plots of land around Sofia have decreased in price by 50%. The trend at the Bulgarian Black Sea coast is exactly the same. In the last 12 months  mainly Bulgarians bought properties near to the big cities according to Dobromir Ganev, executive director of Foros Estate agents. The main reason for this is the world financial crisis and  prospective buyers have become more cautious, especially when applying for mortgages.

A regulated plot of land of 1020 sq m situated between Sofia and Pernik has decreased by 50%  in price and it is now on offer for 12 000 levs (apprx 6 000 Euros). An old two-storey house in a village with a garden of about 1500 sq m can be purchased for 6-7 000 levs (apprx. 3 000 Euros). In the past the prices of rural properties in the area of Bansko, Sunny Beach and Burgas have been artificially increased but now they have fallen dramatically. The purchases of property for investment have almost stopped and most people buy for their own needs.

The financial crisis have affected the sales of land for the construction of industrial developments. All investors have experienced difficulties in financing and several projects in Varna and Sofia have stopped.

The sharpest fall of the prices according to analysts and advisors are in holiday properties. Due to over supply in Bansko only the prices have fallen by 48%. The number of one-bedroom apartments on offer is astonishing and prices range from 780 to 2015 Euros per sq m.

The slowing down of the Bulgarian property market is most obvious at the Black Sea resorts, namely the Sunny Beach and the Golden Sands, and in the mountain ski resorts like Bansko and Pamporovo. The price of properties there have reached their peak levels and the number of purchases has been falling. There is no demand for such properties, while the the properties on offer are many. This is the reason why the Bulgarian banks avoid financing such purchases, as well as the construction of properties along the coast. According to leading business and legal advisers, the prospective investors can not  rely on off-plan sales at the moment. Many hotels along the Bulgarian Black Sea coast have been put up for sale and there are no prospective buyers interested in them. This means that most of them will be acquired by the Bulgarian banks which credited their construction. In the long run if the intensive construction does not stop, many hotels along the coast will have to be demolished like in Spain. However, in order to do this, a new legislative framework needs to be introduced by the Bulgarian parliament, and leading solicitors have been investigating the Spanish experience and preparing the necessary amendments to the current Bulgarian laws. Generally, the lawyers and the law companies seem to be more occupied than anybody else involved in the construction business.

Away from the Black Sea and the mountain resorts, the Bulgarian property market keeps moving because traditionally Bulgarians consider buying a property not only an investment but  most of all a form of security.